Aumirah

Whether patents genuinely matter in today’s dynamic business landscape is complex and context-dependent. Their significance hinges on diverse business objectives and the nature of the industry in question. While patents are deemed indispensable in specific sectors, their importance diminishes in others.

The Perceived Worth of Patents

An undeniable reality is that a substantial majority of patents are economically negligible. Approximately 97% of patents fail to recover filing costs, a statistic that has lingered for years. Moreover, around 50% of patents expire prematurely due to owners opting not to pay requisite maintenance fees, as highlighted by Dennis Crouch, co-director of the Center for Intellectual Property & Entrepreneurship at the University of Missouri School of Law. Even patents filed by research universities intended to be wellsprings of innovation often need help to generate revenue, with fewer than 20% of technology transfer offices breaking even.

Quantifying the actual value of an invention and understanding the cost-recovery mechanisms pose formidable challenges. Some argue that the primary objective of technology transfer is to ‘create impact.’ Regardless, it’s evident that the tangible value derived from patents is relatively low. Despite the availability of such statistics, entrepreneurs often need clarification about the benefits of filing intellectual property.

Contrary to common belief, obtaining a patent is not a waterproof shield against competitors infringing on one’s technology. Instead, it provides a legal avenue for recourse if infringement occurs, enabling the patent holder to pursue litigation. Silicon Valley patent attorney Damon Kali underscores that a patent essentially grants a seat at the table, offering offensive and defensive capabilities. However, the degree of relevance and leverage gained depends on strategic maneuvering and financial capacity.

The Legal Battles

Enforcing patent rights in a court of law is a prolonged and financially intensive process, often spanning three to five years. Recent changes to the patent system have further extended the duration and escalated the costs associated with defending intellectual property.

Consequently, many small businesses and startups lacked more time and financial resources for such legal battles. Apple’s ongoing litigation with Samsung, persisting five years after a significant damages award, is an emblematic case.

While constructing a ‘wall’ of intellectual property around technology might deter infringement, the narrow scope of many patents makes them easily circumvented. Comparisons between patents and real estate, often posited by patent attorneys, prove wishful, as patents merely establish perceived ownership over an idea rather than actual ownership. Judges, juries, and examiners’ subjective interpretation of patents adds further complexity, with virtually identical patents regularly issued.

Powerful companies with expansive patent portfolios and legal teams can leverage their resources to hinder smaller competitors needing more means to mount a robust defense.

Instances Where Patents Come into Play

1-Licensing a Consumer Product Idea

For a new consumer product idea with a typical lifespan of around 18 months, patenting might not be the most prudent approach. Instead, a well-crafted provisional patent application establishing perceived ownership could suffice. Negotiating with licensees to fund subsequent non-provisional patent applications aligns with a strategic and cost-effective approach, especially for companies embracing open innovation.

2-Licensing an Innovation/Complex Idea

In cases where licensing involves innovations demanding significant time and capital, patents become pivotal. Establishing a fortress of intellectual property, encompassing patents, trademarks, copyrights, and trade secrets, is crucial. Continued innovation and strategic use of intellectual property, including potential licensing agreements, contribute to maintaining perceived ownership.

3-Owning a Small Business

For small businesses seeking a competitive edge, patents convey that their innovations are substantial. While patent defense can be challenging, especially against online infringers besieging entrepreneurs, they provide a legal foundation for pursuing infringers. Nonetheless, the efficacy of patent protection hinges on the willingness and ability to defend it.

4-Forming a Startup

Startups aiming to raise capital benefit from an early intellectual property strategy. Filing for provisional patent applications, trademarks, copyrights, and trade secrets can instill confidence in investors. However, it’s crucial to recognize that patents alone are not the primary basis for fundraising; they complement a broader strategy.

Conclusion

The value of patents is nuanced and contingent on business objectives and industry dynamics. While patents offer legal recourse, their actual impact relies on strategic use, financial strength, and a comprehensive understanding of the business landscape.

Intellectual property, including patents, proves valuable but constitutes one facet of a multifaceted business strategy. If you are looking for any information on patents or any help regarding patent services to maximize the potential of your business, Aumirah’s patent experts can assist you 24*7. You may reach us at info@aumirah.com or our website at www.aumirah.com for valuable insights and assistance.


Website | + posts
Anasuya Pradhan
+ posts